I’m reading a great book to my kids called Navigating Early The protagonist is a 13-year-old boy whose mother has recently died. He laments that he has forgotten what her voice sounded like. You empathize with others who have lost their mother, whether fictional or real, and I found myself barely able to finish the page without my voice cracking. He too had lost this essential part of his mother’s being.
Mama used to sing to us as she rocked us to sleep in our nursery. I remember her so clearly singing “Go Tell Aunt Tabby” to my younger siblings. She would always start her voice mails to me, “Hey girl, it’s me….” (my nickname was “Big Girl” since I was the oldest but the “Big” part was dropped when I became old enough to care about such things). I loved the way she laughed when she thought something was genuinely funny.
Thankfully, her voice is still crystal clear and I don’t suspect I’ll ever lose it after knowing it for 37 years. Just like I won’t ever lose the sound of her bedroom shoes, quickly slap, slap, slapping down the hall past my room in the morning as she made her way to the kitchen before the sun rose. Or her hands and feet, as beautiful as any model’s. Her strong arms that lovingly held me as I labored with two of my children. Or her sweet scent. I slept with one of her t-shirts for months after she died as it held faint remembrances of it. She was a beautiful woman, but what I treasure the most about her has absolutely nothing to do with her appearance.
Lately, it seems I’ve been exposed more than usual to the vulnerability of young girls concerned with body image and self esteem. It’s troubling to watch yet I remember all too well being that age and wanting to look like those girls in Seventeen magazine–usually tall with long, beautifully styled hair, thin, flawless skin, gorgeous smiles. You know the ones. Little did I know then that those very girls were looking at other girls our age and wishing the same thing I was.
Our culture hasn’t changed all that much since then, and I am thankful that Lou hasn’t fallen prey to it (yet). It’s nearly impossible not to eventually unless you live under a rock. But I find myself still desperately wishing I could protect her from falling down that deep, dark rabbit hole. Once you’ve fallen, the strength it takes to climb out is nearly insurmountable. I’m not sure I’ve ever known a single woman to avoid it much less escape it entirely.
I’ve lived long enough now to know that no matter how much weight I lose, how much muscle I gain, how I style my hair, or how much I try to slow down wrinkles from appearing, I won’t ever be completely satisfied with all of it from an aesthetic perspective. Perhaps it’s societal influences that contribute the most to the impossibility, but I suspect it’s also simply not in our DNA to be completely satisfied.
But what I’ve also lived long enough to know is that I’m okay with never being perfectly perfect, because it simply. does. not. exist.
Does it mean I should give up on being healthy and fit? Not for a second. But instead of wishing healthy habits would decrease the amount of cellulite on my legs, I’m slowly, ever so slowly, shifting my focus to how much I’m able to do because of that good health. I’d be lying if I didn’t admit that it’s impossible for me to look in the mirror and not find something to critique, but now instead of thinking I can fix it all, I’m aware that the only thing that needs “fixing” is what’s in my head. A lesson only gleaned with the benefit of age.
I joined a local CrossFit gym this past summer and am questioned often from friends and family what the big deal is about. What I love most about this gym is the mindset that everyone is treated like an athlete when they walk through the door, no matter how big or small. While your body will most certainly change if you stick with it long enough, to strive for strength and self-improvement over the holy grail of physique are the primary goals.
If you have thick thighs like I do, the coaches tell you to embrace them because it is their bulk that will see you through 100 wall balls in the gym today and from Springer Mountain to Mt. Katahdin years from now when you thru hike the Appalachian Trail. The weakest in the room are on the same playing field as the strongest, except the weakest are usually being cheered on the loudest for a change.
For me, it’s been an empowering and enlightening experience, both physically and mentally. Strong is the new skinny in this arena, and that’s a cultural paradigm shift I can get on board with and celebrate exuberantly.
And so at the end of the day what should I try to instill and model for my sweet Lou Bird? I certainly don’t know all the answers, but I do know I want her to realize that what she puts in her mouth is far more important than how much of it she eats, that positive self esteem will look much better on her than a makeover, and that the size of her jeans will never, ever be as important as the size of her heart.
I will share with her that I’ve witnessed enough heartache related to body image in someone I loved dearly to cry a river of tears. From this experience I know, without a doubt, that external beauty and strength can only stem from internal resolve and love of self.
I hear her as I write, with her cousin in my bedroom, putting on play makeup. “I don’t like the way I look with eye shadow. I look better without it,” she says as she walks to the bathroom to remove it. She isn’t scared to run around the house in nothing but her underwear, laughing at herself, not even remotely self conscious. She wears the most outlandish outfits she can create with pride, never worrying that someone might make fun of it. When I ask her if she knows how beautiful she is inside and out, she smiles and nods. Yes, indeed, she still loves who she is. Let’s keep it that way.
Julie Gerdes
Great post Nancy. As you know, this topic is very close to my heart too. Since becoming responsible for the well being of a girl, I've become more aware of the gender issues that plague our society with self image being a huge problem with girls. I don't think it's in our DNA to not be satisfied but being competitive and accepted is and when we are bomb barded with images of women/girls that are so airbrushed they look abnormal, we are bound to find ourselves trying to be something that's impossible and feeling bad about ourselves or made to feel bad by others because we don't meet this ideal. We aren't born with an ingrained idea of what is beautiful, that is taught. Looks and the idea of beauty have way too much emphasis in our society for both men/boys and women/girls. So, don't let society off the hook. Awareness is key to bringing about change and slowly but surely the tide will turn and hopefully our daughters won't even have to worry about this for their children.
Noel
Wow, truly excellent writing, Nancy. You really have your mother's gift with words. (I always thought that, among her prodigious talents, she could have just chosen "writer" and excelled in that field as much as nursing, the gym she worked at, being a reverend, ministering at the prison, and mothering – among others.)
I hope it is OK if I share this with a couple of friends with whom it will really resonate. Thanks and we look forward to seeing you this Sunday for Ethiopian food, Nancy!
Nancy
Totally agreed–societal influences are far from off the hook with all this. It perpetuates the lie more than any of it. I do believe, however, that we are born with a sense of what we perceive as beautiful to some degree. Before society even gets its dirty paws on any of us, I personally think there is some degree of evolutionary influence. You can look at the rest of the animal kingdom and see it happening every day. But our culture takes it and runs with it, and it's sickening to see the influence it has on us. I think that's why I like CrossFit so much–in theory, it truly tries to put blinders on you with all that and to just focus on being strong and fit. Not everyone in the room subscribes to that notion completely, but it's a refreshing place to be after having experienced the flip side in so many other places. Thanks for sharing your thoughts–like anything important, ongoing dialogue is the key to change. Emily sure is lucky to have you as her strong and secure Mama–that I know for sure 🙂
Nancy
Mama definitely had the gift–I just like to ramble on and hear myself write 🙂 It's truly therapy sometimes to jot all these thoughts down that keep my insomnia alive and well! It's absolutely okay to share this with someone. Can't wait to see you guys on Sunday!!
Julie Gerdes
You're right Nancy – we, as animals, definitely gravitate towards "beauty". I remember a documentary I watched where they showed very young children pictures of adult faces and asked them which one they liked better and all the children selected faces with a range of what was considered "pretty". The analysis showed the common trait to the preferred faces was symmetry. I just get so angry at how women are portrayed in media and the message it sends to young girls. I look forward to carrying on with this conversation in Sedona :-). We are going to have so much fun! Love ya girl!
Jessica Heard
Your blog always moves me, especially now as I convalesce while raising a nine year old girl. We talk about often about strong, fun, kind and healthy rather than fast, winning or pretty. Its so hard to combat the message they get from all over their world. Thank you for writing.
Also I stumbled across the movie Closure about transracial adoption. I have downloaded it but not seen it yet. I thought you might be interested.
Love – Jessica